Prospective blind comparative clinical study of two point fixation of zygomatic complex fracture using wire and mini plates
نویسندگان
چکیده
BACKGROUND The zygomatic maxillary complex (ZMC) fractures are one of the most frequent injuries of the facial skeleton due to its position and facial contour. Assaults, road traffic accidents and falls are the principal etiologic factors that may cause fractures of zygomatic bone. The different fixation methods are applied to treat the zygomatic bone fractures, with many more classifications which have been described in the literature for the ease of management. The type of the fracture, its severity and associated facial fractures usually interferes the treatment modality. PURPOSE OF STUDY The aim of this paper is to show the results of 18yrs prospective blind comparative study using wire and plate osteosynthesis which needed open reduction and internal fixation involving Type II to Type IV Spissel and Schroll ZMC fractures. MATERIALS AND METHODS Total 80 cases included in the study out of 1780 ZMC cases which were treated using wire and plate osteosynthesis over a period of 18 yrs, involving only Type II to Type IV Spissel and Schroll ZMC fractures. Other types excluded from study to prevent observer bias. All the fixations carried out through Standard Dingman's incision using stainless steel 26 gauze wire and titanium 1.5 mm mini plate system under general anesthesia by single maxillofacial surgeon and evaluated by another maxillofacial surgeon who is blinded for surgical procedure after 2 and 4 wks of follow-up for facial symmetry, wound healing, functional assessment (mouth opening, diplopia), and sensory disturbance. All the data tabulated in Excel software (Microsoft) for statistical analysis. P-value calculated to know the Significance of treatment modality in all aspects. RESULTS Result shows no significant p-values indicating both the operating techniques are equally efficient in the surgical management of ZMC fracture. CONCLUSION Osteosynthesis by mini plates is simple, logical and effective treatment compared to wire osteosynthesis in regard to stability of fracture fragments. Wire osteosynthesis will be helpful in emergency surgeries or where the mini plates are not available. Even though the wire osteosynthesis is economical compared to mini plate fixation; but the time and skill is required for fixation of wires.
منابع مشابه
Rigid internal fixation of zygoma fractures: A comparison of two-point and three-point fixation
Background: Displaced fractures of the zygomatic bone can result in signi›cant functional and aesthetic sequelae. Therefore the treatment must achieve adequate and stable reduction at fracture sites so as to restore the complex multidimensional relationship of the zygoma to the surrounding craniofacial skeleton. Many experimental biophysical studies have compared stability of zygoma after one, ...
متن کاملTreatment of a Mandibular Fracture by Two Perpendicular Mini-Plates
Introduction: In open reduction and internal fixation for the treatment of mandibular fracture, the fixation technique used is very important in reducing post-operative complications and promoting the healing process. This study assessed the results of fixation of the mandible using two mini-plates perpendicular to each other in the lower border of the mandible for fracture treatment. Materi...
متن کاملTreatment of Zygomatic Complex Fractures Using Two Point Fixation under General Anaesthesia
To evaluate the advantages and efficacy of two point mini plate fixation for the zygomatic complex fractures using lateral eye brow and infra orbital approaches for fixing the fronto zygomatic fracture and infra orbital fracture. The zygomatico-maxillary complex functions as the principle buttress of the face and is the cornerstone to an individual’s aesthetic appearance. The zygomatic complex ...
متن کاملSurgical treatment of zygomatic bone fracture using two points fixation versus three point fixation-a randomised prospective clinical trial
BACKGROUND The zygoma plays an important role in the facial contour for both cosmetic and functional reasons; therefore zygomatic bone injuries should be properly diagnosed and adequately treated. Comparison of various surgical approaches and their complications can only be done objectively using outcome measurements which in turn require protocol management and long-term follow up. The prefere...
متن کاملEvaluation of Efficacy of Three-dimensional Stainless Steel Mini-Plates in the Treatment of Fractures of the Mandible: A Prospective Study
INTRODUCTION The purpose of the study was to analyze whether adequate fracture fixation can be achieved by three-dimensional (3D) stainless steel mini-plates its ease of placement, whether the patient can resume function early and to find out the need to do intermaxillary fixation. MATERIALS AND METHODS In the prospective study, we treated 12 patients and 17 fractured sites using 3D mini-plat...
متن کامل